Skip to contents

This function applies the Virtual Population Analysis (VPA) or Cohort analysis (CA). Methods used to estimate stock biomass and fishing mortality per age/length group.

Usage

VPA(
  param,
  catch_columns = NA,
  catch_unit = NA,
  catch_corFac = NA,
  terminalF = NA,
  terminalE = NA,
  analysis_type = "VPA",
  algorithm = "new",
  plus_group = TRUE,
  plot = FALSE,
  LW_unit = "kg",
  landings = NULL,
  sampleWeight = NULL,
  raiseBy = "sample",
  boot = NULL,
  natMort = NULL,
  yearSel = NA,
  yearCombine = FALSE,
  binSize = NA,
  CI = 95
)

Arguments

param

a list consisting of following parameters:

  • midLengths or age: midpoints of the length class (length-frequency data) or ages (age composition data),

  • Linf: infinite length for investigated species in cm [cm],

  • K: growth coefficent for investigated species per year [1/year],

  • t0: theoretical time zero, at which individuals of this species hatch,

  • M: natural mortality [1/year] (numeric value or vector of identical length than midLengths),

  • a: length-weight relationship coefficent (W = a * L^b; in kg/cm^b, or in g/cm^b with LW_unit = "g"),

  • b: length-weight relationship coefficent (W = a * L^b),

  • catch: total catch of the stock per age class or length group, as vector for pseudo cohort analysis, or a matrix with catches of subsequent years to follow a real cohort (or, for length-frequency data, one column per year selected with catch_columns). By default the catch is in numbers (see catch_unit). For length-frequency data with the sampled numbers of fish, provide the total landings with landings instead (see Details).

catch_columns

numerical; indicating the column of the catch matrix which should be used for the analysis.

catch_unit

optional; unit of catch: NA (default; numbers of fish), thousand or million individuals ("'000", "'000000"), or, for the length-based VPA/CA only, the catch in weight per length group ("kg" or "tons"), which is converted into numbers with the mean body weight of each length group. Note that this is the weight of the catch of each length group, not the total landings: for the total landings use landings.

catch_corFac

optional; additional raising factor for the catch, in case the catch does spatially or temporarily not reflect the catch of the stock in a whole year (e.g. landings of only one of several fleets). With boot, one value per sample is possible.

terminalF

the fishing mortality rate of the last age/length group; a single value > 0.

terminalE

the exploitation rate of the last age/length group; a single value > 0 and < 1. Only one of terminalF and terminalE is required; if both are provided, terminalF is used. Both are not used with boot (the fishing mortality of each resample is used instead).

analysis_type

determines which type of assessment should be done, options: "VPA" for age or length-based Virtual Population Analysis, "CA" for age- or length-based Cohort Analysis. Default is "VPA".

algorithm

an Algorithm to use to solve for fishing mortality. The default setting "new" uses optimise, while "old" uses the algorithm described by Sparre and Venema (1998).

plus_group

logical; indicating if the last length group is a plus group (default: TRUE).

plot

logical; indicating whether a plot should be printed

LW_unit

unit of the weight in the length-weight relationship (a): "kg" (default; W in kg) or "g" (W in g, then a is divided by 1000). The mean body weight is in kg and biomass and yield in tonnes.

landings

optional; total landings (or catch) of the stock in kg, one value per sample (raiseBy = "sample") or year (raiseBy = "year"). If provided, param has to be length-frequency data with the sampled numbers of fish, which are raised to the total catch with lfqRaise and summed per year (select the year with catch_columns if there are several). With boot, each resample is raised.

sampleWeight

optional; with landings, the measured weight of the samples in kg (one value per sample or year). By default estimated from the sampled numbers and the length-weight relationship (see lfqRaise).

raiseBy

with landings, "sample" (default) to raise each sample separately or "year" to raise all samples of a year with one factor (see lfqRaise).

boot

optional; an object of class `lfqBoot` with bootstrapped growth parameters, natural mortality (see `natMort`) and fishing mortality (`FM`, from catchCurve with `natMort`). If provided, the length-based VPA (or cohort analysis) is applied to each resampled data set (re-created with lfqResample and the seeds of `boot`) with the growth parameters and mortality rates of the resample: the terminal fishing mortality is the `FM` of the resample and a plus group is created at Linf of the resample. `param` has to be the lfq data used for the bootstrapped growth analysis and contain the parameters `a` and `b` of the length-weight relationship.

natMort

with `boot`, the name of the column in `boot$bootRaw` with natural mortality estimates (e.g. "M_Then").

yearSel

optional; with `boot`, year(s) to be used if the lfq data covers several years.

yearCombine

logical; with `boot`, should the catches of several years be combined? Default = FALSE

binSize

optional; with `boot`, new bin size for the resampled data.

CI

with `boot`, percentage for confidence intervals (Default: 95)

Value

A list with the input parameters and following list objects:

  • classes.num: numeric age classes or length groups (without plus sign),

  • catch.cohort: a vector with the catch values which were used for the analysis (exists only if catch was a matrix),

  • FM_calc: a vector with the ifshing mortality (M),

  • Z: a vector with the total mortality (Z),

  • survivors: a vector with the number of fish surviving to the next age class or length group (same unit than input catch vector),

  • annualMeanNr: ta vector with the mean number of fish per year (same unit than input catch vector),

  • meanBodyWeight: a vector with the mean body weight in kg,

  • meanBiomassTon: a vector with the mean biomass in tons,

  • yieldTon: a vector with the yield in tons,

  • natLoss: a vector with the number of fish died due to natural mortality,

  • plot_mat: matrix with rearranged survivors, nat losses and catches for plotting,

  • raising: with landings, the raising factors (see lfqRaise);

If `boot` is provided, the lfqBoot object with the additional columns `N` (total mean number of fish) and `B` (total mean biomass in tonnes) in `bootRaw`, `maxDen`, `median` and `CI`. The fishing mortality at length of each resample is stored in `misc$FMvecVPA` (used by predict_mod with `boot`). Resamples for which the analysis fails (e.g. FM <= 0) get NA.

Details

The main difference between virtual population analysis (VPA) and cohort analysis (CA) is the step of calculating the fishing mortality per age class or length group. While CA works with an approximation by assuming that all fish are caught during a single day, which makes the calcualtion easier, VPA assumes that the fish are caught continuously, which has to be solved by the trial and error method (Sparre and Venema, 1998). The VPA/CA requires the total catch of the stock in one year (absolute numbers), while most other methods (e.g. ELEFAN, catchCurve) only use the relative length composition of the samples. For length-frequency data, keep the sampled numbers of fish in the lfq data and provide the total landings in weight (landings): the samples are then raised to the total catch in numbers by lfqRaise. Alternatively, catch can contain the total catch per age class or length group in numbers (or '000 numbers) or, for the length-based VPA/CA, in weight per length group (catch_unit). The catch has to be representative for fished species, that means there should not be other fisheries fishing the same stock. If this is the case catch_corFac can be used as a raising factor to account for the proportion of fish caught by other fisheries. Raising the catch with a single factor changes the numbers and biomass, but not the fishing mortality at length; different raising factors per sample change the length composition and, thus, also the fishing mortality at length. When the model should follow a real cohort instead of a pseudo cohort, catch has to be provided as matrix. The model then starts to follow the first age class in the first column. If catch matrix is shorter than the number of age classes, the age or length classes without catch information are omitted. It is recommended to only follow a real cohort if there is enough information for all age classes (test with: dim(catch)[1] <= dim(catch)[2]). If plus_group is TRUE a different calculation for the survivors of the last length group is used (for more details please refer to Sparre & Venema (1998)).

References

Jones, R., 1984. Assessing the effects of changes in exploitation pattern using length composition data (with notes on VPA and cohort analysis). FAO Fish.Tech.Pap., (256): 118p.

Jones, R., 1990. Length-cohort analysis: the importance of choosing the correct growth parameters. Journal du Conseil: ICES Journal of Marine Science, 46(2), 133-139

Pope, J.G., 1972. An investigation of the accuracy of virtual population analysis using cohort analysis. Res.Bull.ICNAF, (9):65-74

Pope, J.G., 1979. A modified cohort analysis in which constant natural mortality is replaced by estimates of predation levels. ICES C.M. 1979/H:16:7p. (mimeo)

Sparre, P., Venema, S.C., 1998. Introduction to tropical fish stock assessment. Part 1. Manual. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper, (306.1, Rev. 2). 407 p.

References for weight-length relationship parameters (a & b): Dorel, D., 1986. Poissons del'Atlantique nord-est relations taille-poids. Institut Francais de Recherche pour l'Exploitation de la Mer. Nantes, France. 165 p.

Examples

#_______________________________________________
# Virtual Popuation Analysis with age-composition data
data(whiting)
output <- VPA(param = whiting, catch_columns = 1, terminalE = 0.5, analysis_type = "VPA")
#> Warning: You did not specify catch_unit. The Method assumes that catch is provided in numbers!
plot(output)

#_______________________________________________
# Pope's Cohort Analysis with age-composition data
data(whiting)
VPA(whiting, terminalE = 0.5, catch_columns = 3, analysis_type = "CA",
   plot= TRUE, plus_group = TRUE)
#> Warning: You did not specify catch_unit. The Method assumes that catch is provided in numbers!

#> $age
#> [1] "0"  "1"  "2"  "3"  "4"  "5"  "6"  "7+"
#> 
#> $M
#> [1] 0.2
#> 
#> $a
#> [1] 0.00984
#> 
#> $b
#> [1] 2.926
#> 
#> $catch
#>   c1974 c1975 c1976 c1977 c1978 c1979 c1980
#> 1   599   239   424   664   685   478   330
#> 2   678   860   431  1004   418   607   288
#> 3  1097   390  1071   532   335   464   323
#> 4   275   298   159   269   203   211   243
#> 5    40    54    75    32    69    86    80
#> 6     6     9    13    18     8    25    31
#> 7     1     8     3     5     5     3     8
#> 8     6     0     1     0     1     1     1
#> 
#> $classes.num
#> [1] 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
#> 
#> $catch.cohort
#> [1]  424  431 1071  159   75   13    3    1
#> 
#> $FM_calc
#> [1] 0.1492871 0.2230187 1.4200502 0.8413866 1.4281781 1.1127664 0.8574983
#> [8] 0.2000000
#> 
#> $Z
#> [1] 0.3492871 0.4230187 1.6200502 1.0413866 1.6281781 1.3127664 1.0574983
#> [8] 0.4000000
#> 
#> $survivors_L1
#> [1] 3378.991458 2382.833156 1560.913857  308.887303  109.026385   21.400448
#> [7]    5.758318    2.000000
#> 
#> $survivors_L2
#> [1] 2382.833156 1560.913857  308.887303  109.026385   21.400448    5.758318
#> [7]    2.000000    0.000000
#> 
#> $annualMeanNr
#> [1] 2851.975658 1942.985614  772.831931  191.918085   53.818399   11.915395
#> [7]    3.553971    5.000000
#> 
#> $natLoss
#> [1] 572.1583023 390.9192989 181.0265541  40.8609183  12.6259370   2.6421295
#> [7]   0.7583183   1.0000000
#> 
#> $plot_mat
#>                       0            1          2           3         4         5
#> survivors  2382.8331561 1560.9138572  308.88730 109.0263848 21.400448  5.758318
#> nat.losses  572.1583023  390.9192989  181.02655  40.8609183 12.625937  2.642129
#> catch       424.0000000  431.0000000 1071.00000 159.0000000 75.000000 13.000000
#> FM_calc       0.1492871    0.2230187    1.42005   0.8413866  1.428178  1.112766
#>                    6   7
#> survivors  2.0000000 0.0
#> nat.losses 0.7583183 1.0
#> catch      3.0000000 1.0
#> FM_calc    0.8574983 0.2
#> 
#> attr(,"class")
#> [1] "VPA"

#_______________________________________________
# Virtual population analysis with length-composition data
data(hake)
VPA(hake, terminalE = 0.5, analysis_type = "VPA", plot = TRUE,
    catch_unit = "'000", plus_group = TRUE)

#> $midLengths
#>  [1]  9 15 21 27 33 39 45 51 57 63 69 75 81 87
#> 
#> $catch
#>  [1]  1823 14463 25227  8134  3889  2959  1871   653   322   228   181    96
#> [13]    16    46
#> 
#> $K
#> [1] 0.1
#> 
#> $Linf
#> [1] 130
#> 
#> $M
#> [1] 0.28
#> 
#> $a
#> [1] 1e-05
#> 
#> $b
#> [1] 3
#> 
#> $FM
#>  [1] 0.04 0.39 1.07 0.65 0.49 0.59 0.65 0.39 0.29 0.31 0.40 0.39 0.11 0.28
#> 
#> $meanValue
#>  [1] 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.5 1.5 2.0 2.0 2.5 2.5 2.5 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
#> 
#> $classes.num
#>  [1]  9 15 21 27 33 39 45 51 57 63 69 75 81 87
#> 
#> $FM_calc
#>  [1] 0.0404695 0.3920945 1.1114882 0.6611807 0.4998841 0.6054955 0.6658446
#>  [8] 0.3923762 0.2925412 0.3129710 0.4115581 0.3992953 0.1105914 0.2800000
#> 
#> $Z
#>  [1] 0.3204695 0.6720945 1.3914882 0.9411807 0.7798841 0.8854955 0.9458446
#>  [8] 0.6723762 0.5725412 0.5929710 0.6915581 0.6792953 0.3905914 0.5600000
#> 
#> $meanBodyWeight
#>  [1]  0.00729  0.03375  0.09261  0.19683  0.35937  0.59319  0.91125  1.32651
#>  [9]  1.85193  2.50047  3.28509  4.21875  5.31441 12.25043
#> 
#> $survivors_L1
#>  [1] 98237294.1 83800824.9 59009903.1 27427742.4 15849521.2  9782380.8
#>  [7]  5454975.2  2797134.9  1678137.4  1047951.7   615982.6   311827.0
#> [13]   148511.6    92000.0
#> 
#> $survivors_L2
#>  [1] 83800824.9 59009903.1 27427742.4 15849521.2  9782380.8  5454975.2
#>  [7]  2797134.9  1678137.4  1047951.7   615982.6   311827.0   148511.6
#> [13]    92000.0        0.0
#> 
#> $catch_numbers
#>  [1]  1823000 14463000 25227000  8134000  3889000  2959000  1871000   653000
#>  [9]   322000   228000   181000    96000    16000    46000
#> 
#> $annualMeanNr
#>  [1] 45047872.6 36886066.1 22696679.4 12301805.0  7779541.6  4886987.8
#>  [7]  2810018.0  1664243.2  1100681.8   728482.7   439812.1   240418.9
#> [13]   144682.0   164285.7
#> 
#> $meanBiomassTon
#>  [1]  328.3990 1244.9047 2101.9395 2421.3643 2795.7339 2898.9123 2560.6289
#>  [8] 2207.6352 2038.3857 1821.5492 1444.8223 1014.2671  768.8995 2012.5706
#> 
#> $yieldTon
#>  [1]   13.28967  488.12625 2336.27247 1601.01522 1397.58993 1755.24921
#>  [7] 1704.94875  866.21103  596.32146  570.10716  594.60129  405.00000
#> [13]   85.03056  563.51978
#> 
#> $natLoss
#>  [1] 12613469.18 10327921.82  6355160.71  3444221.19  2178140.47  1368405.52
#>  [7]   786840.31   465997.53   308185.74   203969.10   123155.60    67315.40
#> [13]    40511.55    46000.00
#> 
#> $plot_mat
#>                           9           15           21           27           33
#> survivors      8.380082e+07 5.900990e+07 2.742774e+07 1.584952e+07 9.782381e+06
#> nat.losses     1.261347e+07 1.032792e+07 6.355161e+06 3.444221e+06 2.178140e+06
#> catch          1.823000e+06 1.446300e+07 2.522700e+07 8.134000e+06 3.889000e+06
#> FM_calc        4.046950e-02 3.920945e-01 1.111488e+00 6.611807e-01 4.998841e-01
#> meanBodyWeight 7.290000e-03 3.375000e-02 9.261000e-02 1.968300e-01 3.593700e-01
#> meanBiomassTon 3.283990e+02 1.244905e+03 2.101939e+03 2.421364e+03 2.795734e+03
#>                          39           45           51           57           63
#> survivors      5.454975e+06 2.797135e+06 1.678137e+06 1.047952e+06 6.159826e+05
#> nat.losses     1.368406e+06 7.868403e+05 4.659975e+05 3.081857e+05 2.039691e+05
#> catch          2.959000e+06 1.871000e+06 6.530000e+05 3.220000e+05 2.280000e+05
#> FM_calc        6.054955e-01 6.658446e-01 3.923762e-01 2.925412e-01 3.129710e-01
#> meanBodyWeight 5.931900e-01 9.112500e-01 1.326510e+00 1.851930e+00 2.500470e+00
#> meanBiomassTon 2.898912e+03 2.560629e+03 2.207635e+03 2.038386e+03 1.821549e+03
#>                          69           75           81          87
#> survivors      3.118270e+05 1.485116e+05 9.200000e+04     0.00000
#> nat.losses     1.231556e+05 6.731540e+04 4.051155e+04 46000.00000
#> catch          1.810000e+05 9.600000e+04 1.600000e+04 46000.00000
#> FM_calc        4.115581e-01 3.992953e-01 1.105914e-01     0.28000
#> meanBodyWeight 3.285090e+00 4.218750e+00 5.314410e+00    12.25043
#> meanBiomassTon 1.444822e+03 1.014267e+03 7.688995e+02  2012.57064
#> 
#> attr(,"class")
#> [1] "VPA"
#_______________________________________________
# Jones's Cohort Analysis with length-composition data
data(hake)
VPA(hake, terminalE = 0.5, analysis_type = "CA", plot = TRUE,
   catch_unit = "'000", plus_group = TRUE)

#> $midLengths
#>  [1]  9 15 21 27 33 39 45 51 57 63 69 75 81 87
#> 
#> $catch
#>  [1]  1823 14463 25227  8134  3889  2959  1871   653   322   228   181    96
#> [13]    16    46
#> 
#> $K
#> [1] 0.1
#> 
#> $Linf
#> [1] 130
#> 
#> $M
#> [1] 0.28
#> 
#> $a
#> [1] 1e-05
#> 
#> $b
#> [1] 3
#> 
#> $FM
#>  [1] 0.04 0.39 1.07 0.65 0.49 0.59 0.65 0.39 0.29 0.31 0.40 0.39 0.11 0.28
#> 
#> $meanValue
#>  [1] 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.5 1.5 2.0 2.0 2.5 2.5 2.5 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
#> 
#> $classes.num
#>  [1]  9 15 21 27 33 39 45 51 57 63 69 75 81 87
#> 
#> $FM_calc
#>  [1] 0.04018074 0.38738204 1.06605819 0.64681567 0.49108991 0.59097400
#>  [7] 0.64619709 0.38547186 0.28815816 0.30753075 0.40125050 0.38938206
#> [13] 0.11013665 0.28000000
#> 
#> $Z
#>  [1] 0.3201807 0.6673820 1.3460582 0.9268157 0.7710899 0.8709740 0.9261971
#>  [8] 0.6654719 0.5681582 0.5875308 0.6812505 0.6693821 0.3901366 0.5600000
#> 
#> $meanBodyWeight
#>  [1]  0.00729  0.03375  0.09261  0.19683  0.35937  0.59319  0.91125  1.32651
#>  [9]  1.85193  2.50047  3.28509  4.21875  5.31441 12.25043
#> 
#> $survivors_L1
#>  [1] 98919295.3 84392697.8 59475831.7 27622964.5 15967837.6  9861484.0
#>  [7]  5500527.2  2818814.8  1691487.1  1056603.3   621014.3   313709.2
#> [13]   148676.7    92000.0
#> 
#> $survivors_L2
#>  [1] 84392697.8 59475831.7 27622964.5 15967837.6  9861484.0  5500527.2
#>  [7]  2818814.8  1691487.1  1056603.3   621014.3   313709.2   148676.7
#> [13]    92000.0        0.0
#> 
#> $catch_numbers
#>  [1]  1823000 14463000 25227000  8134000  3889000  2959000  1871000   653000
#>  [9]   322000   228000   181000    96000    16000    46000
#> 
#> $annualMeanNr
#>  [1] 45369990.9 37335236.3 23663811.5 12575452.9  7919120.1  5006988.5
#>  [7]  2895401.4  1694027.7  1117441.9   741389.3   451089.8   246544.5
#> [13]   145274.1   164285.7
#> 
#> $meanBiomassTon
#>  [1]  330.7472 1260.0642 2191.5056 2475.2264 2845.8942 2970.0955 2638.4346
#>  [8] 2247.1447 2069.4242 1853.8216 1481.8705 1040.1095  772.0460 2012.5706
#> 
#> $yieldTon
#>  [1]   13.28967  488.12625 2336.27247 1601.01522 1397.58993 1755.24921
#>  [7] 1704.94875  866.21103  596.32146  570.10716  594.60129  405.00000
#> [13]   85.03056  563.51978
#> 
#> $natLoss
#>  [1] 12703597.45 10453866.16  6625867.22  3521126.83  2217353.64  1401956.77
#>  [7]   810712.41   474327.75   312883.73   207589.00   126305.14    69032.46
#> [13]    40676.74    46000.00
#> 
#> $plot_mat
#>                           9           15           21           27           33
#> survivors      8.439270e+07 5.947583e+07 2.762296e+07 1.596784e+07 9.861484e+06
#> nat.losses     1.270360e+07 1.045387e+07 6.625867e+06 3.521127e+06 2.217354e+06
#> catch          1.823000e+06 1.446300e+07 2.522700e+07 8.134000e+06 3.889000e+06
#> FM_calc        4.018074e-02 3.873820e-01 1.066058e+00 6.468157e-01 4.910899e-01
#> meanBodyWeight 7.290000e-03 3.375000e-02 9.261000e-02 1.968300e-01 3.593700e-01
#> meanBiomassTon 3.307472e+02 1.260064e+03 2.191506e+03 2.475226e+03 2.845894e+03
#>                          39           45           51           57           63
#> survivors      5.500527e+06 2.818815e+06 1.691487e+06 1.056603e+06 6.210143e+05
#> nat.losses     1.401957e+06 8.107124e+05 4.743278e+05 3.128837e+05 2.075890e+05
#> catch          2.959000e+06 1.871000e+06 6.530000e+05 3.220000e+05 2.280000e+05
#> FM_calc        5.909740e-01 6.461971e-01 3.854719e-01 2.881582e-01 3.075308e-01
#> meanBodyWeight 5.931900e-01 9.112500e-01 1.326510e+00 1.851930e+00 2.500470e+00
#> meanBiomassTon 2.970095e+03 2.638435e+03 2.247145e+03 2.069424e+03 1.853822e+03
#>                          69           75           81          87
#> survivors      3.137092e+05 1.486767e+05 9.200000e+04     0.00000
#> nat.losses     1.263051e+05 6.903246e+04 4.067674e+04 46000.00000
#> catch          1.810000e+05 9.600000e+04 1.600000e+04 46000.00000
#> FM_calc        4.012505e-01 3.893821e-01 1.101366e-01     0.28000
#> meanBodyWeight 3.285090e+00 4.218750e+00 5.314410e+00    12.25043
#> meanBiomassTon 1.481871e+03 1.040110e+03 7.720460e+02  2012.57064
#> 
#> attr(,"class")
#> [1] "VPA"

#_______________________________________________
# Length-based VPA with sampled length-frequency data and total landings
data(synLFQ7)
lfq <- synLFQ7
lfq$par <- list(Linf = 123, K = 0.2, t0 = 0, M = 0.2, a = 0.015, b = 3)
## plus group below Linf
pg <- lfq$midLengths[max(which(lfq$midLengths < lfq$par$Linf))]
lfq <- lfqModify(lfq, plus_group = pg)
## landings in kg at the sampling dates (one value per sample)
landings <- seq(20000, 40000, length.out = length(lfq$dates))
res <- VPA(lfq, landings = landings, terminalE = 0.5, LW_unit = "g",
           plus_group = TRUE)
res$raising
#>       sample landings sampleWeight estimated   factor
#> 1 2016-01-01 20000.00     14834.87      TRUE 1.348175
#> 2 2016-03-02 22857.14     15273.72      TRUE 1.496501
#> 3 2016-04-02 25714.29     15653.61      TRUE 1.642706
#> 4 2016-07-02 28571.43     15968.56      TRUE 1.789230
#> 5 2016-08-01 31428.57     16545.54      TRUE 1.899519
#> 6 2016-10-01 34285.71     14377.82      TRUE 2.384626
#> 7 2016-11-01 37142.86     14505.44      TRUE 2.560616
#> 8 2016-12-01 40000.00     14847.40      TRUE 2.694075
plot(res)